Assessing the Validity of the Exclusion of Night-time Thermal Comfort in Tourism Climate Indices

Abstract

Biometeorological indices are instruments that can be used to streamline complex climatic information for economic and other decision-making. Indices hold inherent assumptions where the use of an index is only reliable and valuable if those assumptions are true. The Holiday Climate Index (HCI) is presented as the improved version of the TCI, with a key difference being the removal of night-time thermal comfort due to the assumption that air conditioning is ubiquitous throughout Europe. This study investigated the validity of this exclusion of night-time thermal comfort in tourism climate indices, particularly for the HCI using the six European cities for which the index was developed – Barcelona, Stockholm, London, Istanbul, Paris and Rome. The assumption of ubiquitous air conditioning was investigated using Booking.com accommodation listings, the night-time economy and prevalence of night-time activities outside of each accommodation establishment, and whether tourists experienced adverse thermal comfort during the night through posted reviews. Without the air conditioning filter applied, the proportion of listings categorized as offering air conditioning ranged from 28.8% for Stockholm to 98.9% for Rome. With the filter applied, the proportions ranged from 96.4% for Stockholm and 99.0% for Paris. A total of 24,252 TripAdvisor reviews were also examined for both accommodation establishments and night-time tourist activities. The reviews were manually examined for the mention of weather, climate, night-time temperature and air conditioning. The findings of this study exhibit a range of night-time activities, many of which are outdoors, where tourists did comment on night-time thermal comfort. The research disproves the claim of the original authors, and it was found that air conditioning is not ubiquitous. Therefore, the assumption that the HCI is based on is problematic, and the index should be used with caution. Moreover, a similar approach in index validity testing should be performed prior to future studies seeking to apply indices.