School of Geography, Archaeology and Environmental Studies (ETDs)
Permanent URI for this communityhttps://hdl.handle.net/10539/38007
Browse
Search Results
Item A geographical analysis of the impacts of construction and demolition waste on wetland functionality in South Africa: a study of Gauteng province(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024-09) Mangoro, Ngonidzashe; Kubanza, Nzalalemba Serge; Mulala, Danny SimateleThe purpose of this study was to investigate construction and demolition waste management processes in sub-Saharan Africa and how they affect wetland ecosystems, using South Africa as a case study. Construction and demolition (CDW) waste has become a massive urban environmental challenge on a global scale, but more so in developing countries found in sub-Saharan Africa. In the context of South Africa, construction and demolition waste is not a waste stream taken seriously by local and national authorities because it is ‘general waste that does not pose an immediate threat to the environment. This position is premised on the idea that construction and demolition waste is generally inert (chemically inactive) and therefore cannot cause an immediate environmental risk. In this study, it is argued that the environmental risk of waste goes beyond the embedded chemical constituencies because some waste streams can cause immediate environmental risk through their physical properties depending on the location of disposal. It is further argued that although CDW is generally inert, disposal in wetlands immediately disrupts the way wetland ecosystem’s function, causing several environmental risks. To mitigate the environmental threats posed by construction and demolition waste, this study proposes a change in the methodological approaches and strategies deployed to manage the waste stream, such as by introducing a hybrid of circular economy and industrial ecology to minimize or eliminate waste production. This study involved several data collection and analysis methods. Using a combination of qualitative and quantitative studies methods, data was collected with the goal to understand the perceptions of experts on how construction and demolition waste management in South Africa affects wetland ecosystems and what can be done to effectively manage the waste stream in the context of a developing country. Data informing this study were collected through semi-structured interviews and surveys in the province of Gauteng, specifically in the City of Johannesburg and City of Ekurhuleni Municipalities, where there is massive illegal dumping in wetlands for various reasons. Furthermore, apart from the use of semi-structured interviews and surveys, a digital elevation model was generated in ArcGIS Pro 10.1 software to measure the effects of construction and demolition waste on wetlands in the study area. The approach to this study using both qualitative and quantitative methods was crucial because it provided human perceptions which were accurately corroborated by GIS software. The study found that construction and demolition waste management in South Africa is affected by several challenges that lead to massive illegal dumping in critical ecological ecosystems such as wetlands. In a broad sense, the major challenge to sustainable construction and demolition waste management in South Africa is institutional failure at both the local and national levels. Local authorities such as municipalities are characterized by massive corruption, poor funding, and lack of strategic technologies among other things, while at the national level, there is massive interference with municipal affairs through bureaucratic delays in the disbursement of municipal funds. A combination of these and other factors leads to illegal dumping of construction and demolition waste across the Gauteng Province, particularly in wetlands in low-income areas. The data informing this study reveals that dumping construction and demolition waste in wetlands causes an immediate threat to the existence of wetlands through massive sedimentation with insoluble materials. It is ultimately found that construction and demolition waste destroy the ability of wetlands to offer ecosystem services such as flood attenuation, carbon sequestration, water filtration, and habitat provision, among other functions, leading to environmental events such as flooding. A combination of circular economy and industrial ecology can be one of the ways that can be deployed to effectively and sustainably manage construction and demolition waste in South Africa. The circular economy and its three principles of ‘reduce’, ‘recycle’, and ‘reuse’ has been successfully deployed in developed countries in the European Union, where recycling has topped 70% of the total construction waste generated. Industrial ecology with its analogy of industrial ecoparks has been deployed in the European Union with immense success, until more attention was directed to circular economy. With an increase in municipal funding and introduction of a construction waste information system, a combination of ‘circular economy’ and ‘industrial ecology’ can significantly help to reduce pressure on wetlands and the environment at large. Even though the methodological improvements suggested above could significantly reduce pressure on wetlands, the implementation could be faced with institutional challenges. Therefore, it is argued that urgent institutional transformation is required to make tangible changes in the field of construction and demolition waste management. It is recommended that there should be increased law enforcement to curb widespread illegal dumping in South Africa’s major cities. It is also recommended that, like in Europe, South Africa must introduce tailor-made legislation of policies for construction and demolition waste alone. Promulgation of dedicated legislation provides clear direction on how the waste stream is managed and who is responsible for specific roles. Furthermore, dedicated legislation can be a crucial tool to deliver sustainable construction and demolition waste management in South Africa because it can be used to encourage the use of recycled aggregates and limit the amount of illegal dumping or extraction of materials from the environment. Finally, dedicated construction and demolition waste legislation can be used to shift from the traditional view of pollution or contamination through toxicity, and so the value of this study is immediately apparent.Item Assessing the Validity of the Exclusion of Night-time Thermal Comfort in Tourism Climate Indices(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024-09) Mnguni, Zandizoloyiso; Fitchett, JenniferBiometeorological indices are instruments that can be used to streamline complex climatic information for economic and other decision-making. Indices hold inherent assumptions where the use of an index is only reliable and valuable if those assumptions are true. The Holiday Climate Index (HCI) is presented as the improved version of the TCI, with a key difference being the removal of night-time thermal comfort due to the assumption that air conditioning is ubiquitous throughout Europe. This study investigated the validity of this exclusion of night-time thermal comfort in tourism climate indices, particularly for the HCI using the six European cities for which the index was developed – Barcelona, Stockholm, London, Istanbul, Paris and Rome. The assumption of ubiquitous air conditioning was investigated using Booking.com accommodation listings, the night-time economy and prevalence of night-time activities outside of each accommodation establishment, and whether tourists experienced adverse thermal comfort during the night through posted reviews. Without the air conditioning filter applied, the proportion of listings categorized as offering air conditioning ranged from 28.8% for Stockholm to 98.9% for Rome. With the filter applied, the proportions ranged from 96.4% for Stockholm and 99.0% for Paris. A total of 24,252 TripAdvisor reviews were also examined for both accommodation establishments and night-time tourist activities. The reviews were manually examined for the mention of weather, climate, night-time temperature and air conditioning. The findings of this study exhibit a range of night-time activities, many of which are outdoors, where tourists did comment on night-time thermal comfort. The research disproves the claim of the original authors, and it was found that air conditioning is not ubiquitous. Therefore, the assumption that the HCI is based on is problematic, and the index should be used with caution. Moreover, a similar approach in index validity testing should be performed prior to future studies seeking to apply indices.Item Assessing and comparing the performance of different machine learning regression algorithms in predicting Chlorophyll-a concentration in the Vaal Dam, Gauteng(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024-03) Mahamuza, Phemelo Hope; Adam, ElhadiThe state of Vaal Dam is influenced by various land uses surrounding the Dam, including agricultural activities, mining operations, industrial enterprises, urban settlements, and nature reserves. Mining activities, farming practices, and sewage outflows from nearby villages led to access contamination within the Dam, increasing algal bloom levels. Sentinel-2 MSI data were utilized to forecast and comprehend the spatial pattern of Chlorophyll-a concentration, indicating algal bloom occurrence in the Vaal Dam. Targeting Sentinel-2 Level-1C, the image was preprocessed on the Google Earth Engine (GEE) with acquisition dates from 25 – 26 October 30, 2016, corresponding to the on-site data collection between October 26 and October 28, 2016. Due to limited resources, up-to-date data on the Vaal Dam could not be collected. However, since this study focuses on applying various machine learning regression models to predict chlorophyll-a levels in waterbodies, the dataset is used to test the models rather than reflect the current state of the Vaal Dam. The dataset, comprising 23 samples, was divided into 70% training and 30% test sets, allowing for comprehensive model evaluation. Band ratio reflectance values were extracted from the satellite image and correlated with in-field Chlorophyll-a values. The highest correlation coefficient values were utilized to train five machine-learning models employed in this study: Random Forest (RF), Support Vector Regression (SVR), Least Absolute Shrinkage and Selection Operator (LASSO), Ridge Regression, and Multilinear Regression (MLR). Each model underwent training with ten iterations each; the best learning iteration was then used to generate the final Chlorophyll-a predictive model. The predictive models were validated using the Sentinel-2 MSI satellite data and in-situ measurements using R2, RMSE, and MAPE. Among the five machine learning algorithms trained, RF performed the best, with an R2 of 0.86 and 0.95, an RMSE of 1.38 and 0.8, and MAPE of 15.09% and 10.92% for the training and testing sets, respectively, indicating its ability to handle small, non-linear datasets. SVR also demonstrated a fair performance, particularly in handling multicollinearity in the data points with an R2 of 0.68 and 0.87, an RMSE of 2.37 and 1.56, and MAPE of 18.13% and 19.28% for the training and testing sets, respectively. The spatial pattern of Chlorophyll-a concentrations, mapped from the RF model, indicated that high concentrations of Chlorophyll-a are along the Dam shorelines, suggesting a significant impact of land use activities on pollution levels. This study emphasizes the importance of selecting suitable machine learning algorithms tailored to the dataset's characteristics. RF and SVR demonstrated proficiency in handling nonlinearity, with RF displaying enhanced generalization and resistance to overfitting. Limited field data evenly distributed across the Dam and satellite overpass dates may affect result accuracy. Future research should align satellite pass dates with fieldwork dates and ensure an even distribution of in-field samples across the Dam to represent all land uses and concentration levels.Item GIS-Based Location-Allocation Modelling of School Accessibility in the Bojanala Platinum District Municipality, South Africa(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024-09) Molefe, Kebarileng Christinah; Atif, IqraSchool accessibility modelling performs a crucial part in guaranteeing that educational institutions are physically and practically reachable by every student, irrespective of their abilities, disabilities, or socioeconomic status. Neglecting school accessibility perpetuates inequality, reinforces negative stereotypes, and isolates affected students. Therefore, the principal goal of this research was to evaluate the distribution of schools across the Bojanala Platinum District Municipality, focusing on their accessibility to local communities. The study employed an integrated approach, combining geostatistical techniques, location-allocation modelling, and multicriteria decision analysis. By considering both quantitative data and spatial relationships, these methodologies contributed to robust decision-making and informed policy recommendations. The study utilized population data and school-related information sourced from the Department of Education and the HUMDATA websites, both dated to the year 2020. The study examined the distribution of schools in the Bojanala Platinum District Municipality. It was discovered that the schools were clustered, with a concentration in the Rustenburg local municipality, followed by Madibeng. However, a significant inequality in school access was evident. Secondary school students faced the greatest vulnerability, as most accessible schools primarily served primary students. To address this, potential school sites were proposed across the district. The study emphasizes the need for effective interventions by educational administrators and policymakers to eliminate this inequality. This study recommends the establishment of new schools in underserved regions, strategically enhance existing schools, and maximize school accessibility for all residents. Adequate school provision promotes equity, reduces travel burdens, and strengthens community bonds.Item Remote sensing-based assessment of mangrove forest changes and related regulatory frameworks for the sustainability and conservation of coastal ecosystems in Zanzibar Island, Tanzania-East Africa(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024-10) Mohamed, Mohamed Khalfan; Adam, ElhadiMangroves are vital components of the world's coastal ecosystems, yet they face significant threats from storm surges, tidal waves, commercial aquaculture, and expanding human settlements. These challenges have heightened the need for accurate mangrove maps to gauge ecosystem degradation. However, mapping mangroves at species and community levels is challenging due to the inaccessibility of these environments. Remote sensing offers an efficient alternative to conventional field-based methods by enabling data collection in these challenging ecosystems. This study aimed to apply remote sensing techniques to map mangrove forest changes and species in two protected bays in Zanzibar, Tanzania. The thesis focuses on four key areas. First, it examines the history of mangrove management in Zanzibar, from colonial times (1890) to the present, highlighting policies, laws, and community involvement in conservation. The colonial authority implemented several land administration laws and regulations to protect mangrove forests. However, mangrove forests suffered significant degradation from 1930 to the end of World War II. The post-independence policy framework established the legal foundation for the introduction of community involvement in mangrove conservation. The legal foundation for introducing community participation in mangrove protection was established by post-independence policy structures such as the National Forest Conservation and Management Act of 1996. Nevertheless, sustainable mangrove use remains inadequate. Second, the study compared community perceptions of mangrove ecosystem services using chi-squared tests and one-way ANOVA. Household surveys showed that provisioning services (PS) were the most identified (84%). Supporting (SS), regulating (RS), and cultural services (CS) were rated by 46.2%, 45.4%, and 21.0%, respectively. Statistical analyses indicated significant differences in the awareness of RS (χ2 = 6.061, p = 0.014) and SS (χ2 = 6.006, p = 0.014) between Chwaka, Charawe, Ukongoroni, Unguja Ukuu, and Uzi wards. There were no significant differences in the identification of PS (χ2 = 1.510, p = 0.919) and CS (χ2 = 1.601, p = 0.901). The study found that residents’ occupations did not determine their reliance on mangrove ecosystem services (χ2 = 8.015; p = 0.1554). Third, changes in mangrove cover in Menai Bay and Chwaka Bay between 1973 and 2020 were analyzed using Landsat data. TerrSet geospatial software was used to classify land cover. The SEGMENTATION module grouped pixels based on spectral similarity, and the images segments were transformed into training sites and signature classes using the SEGTRAIN module. Finally, the segments were classified with the SEGCLASS module into a pixel-based land cover map. Separation of land cover classes was determined using the Jeffries–Matusita (J-M) distance and the transformed divergence (TD) index. For Chwaka Bay, overall classification accuracy ranged from 82.5% to 92.7%, while for Menai Bay, it ranged between 85.5% and 94.5%. Producer and user accuracies ranged from 72% to 100%, with kappa coefficients (κ) between 0.72 and 0.90. Menai Bay experienced a 6.8 ha yearly decline in mangrove cover between 1973 and 2020, while Chwaka Bay saw a 48.5 ha annual decrease. Fourth, the study aimed to map mangrove species in Menai Bay using metrics extracted from the Landsat 9 OLI-2 dataset, i.e., vegetation indices (VIs) and gray-level co-occurrence matrices (GLCMs). A critical step in this study was identifying the contribution of vegetation indices and texture features to classifying mangroves. Training data from very high-resolution (VHR) unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) data covering parts of the study area helped identify five major mangrove species, i.e., Rhizophora mucronata, Ceriops tagal, Sonneratia alba, Avicennia marina, and Bruguira gymnorrhiza. Results showed that textural features attained overall classification accuracy of 68.29% (kappa = 0.62) and 67.07% (kappa = 0.60) for random forest (RF) and support vector machine (SVM), respectively. Vegetation indices (VIs) recorded overall accuracy of 72.64% (kappa = 0.67) and 67.78% (kappa = 0.61) for RF and SVM. Overall, this study demonstrates the potential of remote sensing technologies for mapping mangrove forest changes and species in challenging environments like Zanzibar’s protected bays. By integrating historical policy analysis with modern geospatial techniques, the research highlights the significant role of both legal frameworks and community involvement in mangrove conservation. The community surveys underscore the varying perceptions of mangrove ecosystem services across different wards, with provisioning services being the most recognized. These findings underscore the importance of advancing remote sensing applications and refining conservation strategies to ensure the sustainability of mangrove ecosystems. Additionally, the analysis of long-term changes in mangrove cover from 1973 to 2020 reveals a concerning decline, particularly in Chwaka Bay. Lastly, the study’s classification of mangrove species using Landsat 9 OLI-2 data, vegetation indices, and texture metrics achieved notable accuracy, emphasizing the value of remote sensing in distinguishing species-level characteristics.Item Integrating Sentinel-1/2 and machine learning models for mapping fruit tree species in heterogeneous landscapes of Limpopo(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024-10) Chabalala, Yingisani Winny; Adam, ElhadiFrom ancient times to this century, Africa has relied chiefly on agriculture for survival. Crop type maps are crucial for agricultural management, sustainable farming systems, and realizing food security. Agronomists, agricultural extension officers, policymakers, and the government rely on crop type spatial distribution information to make informed decisions and optimize resource allocation for sustainable agricultural management. Attaining food security for all is an urgent need in Africa. However, the farming landscapes predominately comprise fragmented smallholder heterogeneous farms. The farming systems include intercropping and cultivating different crops that require different management strategies. This results in within-class spectral similarities and intra-spectral variability due to similar canopy structures and different phenologies, which complicates the application of remote sensing in crop type mapping. The free availability of Copernicus products such as Sentinel 1 and 2 have high temporal, spectral, and spatial resolution suitable for mapping smallholder agriculture. Thus, this research aimed to integrate Sentinel-1/2 and machine learning models for mapping fruit tree species in heterogeneous landscapes of Limpopo. First, the research tested the applicability of sampling techniques and five mapping classifiers (i.e., Random Forest (RF), Support vector Machine (SVM), Adaptive Boosting (AdaBoost), Gradient Boosting (GB), and eXtreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost) in mapping fruit trees and co-existing land use types. The original dataset was under-sampled randomly into two balanced datasets (i.e., Dataset 1 and Dataset 2) consisting of 100 and 150 sample points. Furthermore, the imbalanced ratio from the original dataset was reduced by applying different sampling strategies to extract four imbalanced datasets (i.e., at 40%, 50%, 60%, and 70%), which resulted in the formation of Dataset 3, Dataset 4, and Dataset 5, respectively. These samples, together with the original dataset (i.e., Dataset 7), were used as input to Sentinel‑2 (S2) data using adaptive boosting (AdaBoost), gradient boosting (GB), random forest (RF), support vector machine (SVM), and eXtreme gradient boost (XGBoost) machine learning algorithms. The results showed that reducing the amount of imbalanced ratio by randomly under-sampling the original imbalanced dataset could increase the classification accuracy to 71% using the SVM classifier and 60% of the original dataset. Individually, the majority of the crop types were classified with an F1 score of between 60% and 100%. Secondly, the research independently assessed the effectiveness of Sentinel-1 (S1) and Sentinel-2 (S2) data for fruit tree mapping using random forest (RF) and support vector machine (SVM) classifiers. Four models were tested using each sensor independently and fusing both sensors. From the fused model, features were ranked using the RF mean decrease accuracy (MDA) and forward variable selection (FVS) to identify optimal spectral windows to classify fruit trees. The best fruit tree map with an overall accuracy (OA) of 0.91.6% with a kappa coefficient of 0.91% was produced using the RF MDA and FVS model and SVM classifier. The application of SVM to S1, S2, S2 selected variables and S1S2 fusion independently produced OA = 27.64, Kappa coefficient = 0.13%; OA= 87%, Kappa coefficient = 86.89%; OA = 69.33, Kappa coefficient = 69. %; A = 87.01%, Kappa coefficient = 87%, respectively. The green (B3), SWIR_2 (B10), and vertical horizontal (VH) polarization bands were identified as the optimal spectral features for S2 and S1 data, respectively. The third part of the research identified the optimal growth window period in which fruit trees can be detected with high accuracy. Phenological metrics were extracted from 12 months (i.e., January to December) of Sentinel-2 (S2) data and were used to classify fruit trees using a random forest (RF) classifier in a Google Earth Engine environment. The results showed that fruit trees can be detected and mapped with high accuracy during winter months (i.e., April-July) with an overall accuracy (OA) of 84.89% and a kappa coefficient of 83%. The user accuracy ranged from 62 to 100%, while the producer accuracy ranged from 60 to 100%. The fruit trees were mostly differentiated from co-existing land use types using the short infrared and the red-edge bands. The fourth part of the thesis attempted to increase fruit tree classification accuracy by classifying optimal Sentinel-2 images acquired during the fruit trees' critical growth stages using a Deep Neural Network (DNN) model. This was achieved by applying phenological metrics derived from Sentinel-2 images acquired during optimal crop-growing seasons (i.e., flowering, fruiting, harvesting). The DNN models were optimized by tuning the hyperparameters to achieve the best classification results. The DNN produced an OA of 86.96%, 88.64%, 86.76%, and 87.25% for April, May, June, and July images, respectively. The results indicate the DNN models were robust and stable across the selected fruit growth periods. This research has shown that earth observation (EO) data such as Sentinel 1 and 2 can be used to map fruit trees in fragmented sub-tropical horticultural landscapes characterized by different environmental conditions and different crop cultivars operating under different management practices. The research results will assist agricultural stakeholders (i.e., farm managers, agronomists, agricultural extension officers, and policymakers) in allocating agricultural resources, devising effective agricultural management strategies, and attaining sustainable agriculture and food security.Item An integrated approach for detecting and monitoring the Campuloclinium macrocephalum (Less) DC using the MaxEnt and machine learning models in the Cradle Nature Reserve, South Africa(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Makobe, Benjamin; Mhangara, PaidamoyoThe invasion of ecosystems by invasive plants is considered as one of the major human- induced global environmental change. The uncontrolled expansion of invasive alien plants is gaining international attention, and remote sensing technology is adopted to accurately detect and monitor the spread of invasive plants locally and globally. The Greater Cradle nature reserve is a world heritage site and intense research site for archaeology and paleontology.It was accorded the world status by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organizations (UNESCO) in 1991 due to its variety of biodiversity present and carries information of significance about the evolution of mankind. The invasion of Campuloclinium macrocephalum (pompom weed) at the Cradle nature reserve is downgrading the world status accorded to the site, lowers the grazing capacity for game animals and replaces the native vegetation. This research study explored the capability of Sentinel-2A multispectral imagery in mapping the spatial distribution of pompom weed at the nature reserve between 2019 and 2024. The non-parametric classification models, support vector machine (SVM) and random forests (RF) were evaluated to accurately detect, and discriminate pompom weed against the co-existing land cover types. Additionally, the species distribution modelling MaxEnt Entropy was incorporated to model spatial distribution and pompom weed habitat suitability. The findings indicates that SVM yielded 44% and 50.7% spatial coverage of pompom weed at the nature reserve in 2019 and 2024, respectively. Whereas, the RF model indicates that the spatial coverage of pompom weed was 31.1% and 39.3% in 2019 and 2024, respectively. The MaxEnt model identified both soil and rainfall as the most important environmental factors in fostering the aggressive proliferation of pompom weed at nature reserves. The MaxEnt predictive model obtained an area under curve score of 0.94, indicating outstanding prediction model performance. SVM and RF models had classification accuracy above 75%, indicating that they could distinguish pompom weeds from existing land cover types. The preliminary results of this study call for attention in using predictive models in predicting current and future spatial distribution of invasive weeds, for effective eradication control and environmental management.Item SBLS Lithic Technology and its Behavioural Implications(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Bielderman, Sebastian Christopher; Wurz, SarahIn the Middle Stone Age (MSA) of the southern Cape in South Africa significant research has been undertaken to understand the behaviours linked to coastal adaptation as well as the exploitation of terrestrial resources, however but relatively little is understood on how lithic technology relates to human behaviour during certain MSA periods in this region. The Silty Black Soils (SBLS) layer at Klasies River main site (KRM), which is older than 110 000 years ago, falls within one of these lesser understood periods and has yielded lithic material in association with both faunal and shellfish remains and other important features such as hearths. Understanding the behaviours of the SBLS is significant in broadening our understanding of the MSA I/earlier MSA technologies. Through the analysis of the Chaî ne Opé ratoire (or production sequence), macro-fractures, and the Tip Cross-Sectional Area of the SBLS lithics, significant information on the manufacturing and utilisation behaviours has been inferred. The data gained from these analyses allow for widespread behavioural comparison between the SBLS, overlaying KRM layers, and other sites. Broadly speaking, the assemblage shares several technological signatures with the MSA I/Klasies River technology previously identified at KRM and on a technological attribute level widespread similarities are shared with several MIS 5 assemblages in South Africa; an example of this is the widespread use of locally available raw materials. There is, however, a key behavioural inference which clearly indicates that the SBLS is different to other assemblages both at KRM and in the broader MIS 5. The SBLS points and their TCSA values point towards significantly smaller points. This supports a different and varied hunting approach which is unique to KRM during this period at KRM