Using Mnemonic and Sub-lexic Reinforcement Techniques to Enhance Reading Abilities among Grade Three Learners with Dyslexia in Primary Schools in Mpumalanga: Analysis of Age and Gender Differences

Abstract

Learners with dyslexia (LWD) have difficulties in accurate and fluent word recognition and poor spelling and decoding abilities. Such learners also face challenges in various areas. In addition, dyslexia is linked with experiences of stigmatization and lowered self- concept. However, every learner in the society including those with dyslexia who have been excluded from the formal education system, must get access to quality education without discrimination. In South Africa, White Paper 6 outlines a national strategy for systematically addressing and removing barriers to learning through establishing full- service schools, converting special schools into resource centres, training education managers and teachers, and developing institutional and district support structures and pursuing a funding strategy. However, several studies report that LWD are still many and disadvantaged in the inclusive school set-ups. LWD continue to face academic, social, and psychological challenges in school and therefore early interventions are crucial for the development of these learners. This study aimed to examine effectiveness of mnemonic and sub-lexical reinforcement techniques in enhancing reading abilities among grade three LWD in two public schools in Mpumalanga, South Africa and was guided by two theories: Skinner’s reinforcement theory and the Information Processing Theory (IPT). The study was also informed by the Human Rights Model of Disability and the Inclusive Pedagogical Approach. This study was anchored on pragmatic research paradigm. Within the mixed methods methodology, the Sequential Triangulation design guided the data collection process. The sample size consisted of 43 learners: 23 grade three LWD from the intervention and 20 learners from the control schools. Pre-and post- tests were administered to the learners during the first three months and during the second half of the research period which took 6 months using the quantitative sample of 43 LWD. The initial test was the Bangor Dyslexia test that was administered to all grade three learners from both the experimental and the control schools. The study’s qualitative data, in the form of interviews, was also undertaken in the second phase of the data collection period where 6 parents of LWD were selected using purposive sampling and 3 English Grade three teachers, plus the principal and the deputy principal underwent semi- structured in-depth interviews. The research tools used were reading tests, short reading comprehension passage, questionnaires, and interview guides. Validity of questionnaires was ensured by Keyser Meyer Oklin test while reliability was ascertained by use of xv Cronbach’s alpha. Quantitative data were analyzed using both descriptive and inferential statistics whereas the qualitative data was analyzed using thematic analysis. The study findings indicated that the use of mnemonic reinforcement techniques to enhance reading abilities among grade three learners with dyslexia in primary schools is highly effective. The findings further revealed that repeated reading as a form of sub- lexical reinforcement techniques is effective in enhancing reading abilities among learners with dyslexia. The findings also revealed that there is a significant effect of gender in influencing enhancement of reading performance by mnemonic intervention, with the female learners having better scores than males. The findings indicated that girls had comparatively higher improvement in performance than the boys in the two components of reading ability (reading and comprehension) and in the overall reading ability, after having gone through sub-lexical intervention. The findings further indicated that generally older children in the intervention group had relatively higher improvement in performance in overall reading ability and its two components (reading and comprehension) than the younger children in same group. The findings indicated that there was statistically significant difference in reading scores between younger and older children among grade three LWD who received sub-lexical treatment, with older learners having higher scores than younger learners. The study recommends that the Department of Basic Education should revise the policy that reading is tested from grade one, instead of from grade three, and that those who are not able to read do not proceed until and unless they are able to read. Moreover, the Department of Basic Education should organize workshops that train teachers in various approaches on how to improve reading of learners with reading problems because the workshops would help teachers by equipping them with the most widely used approaches to reading instruction to enhance learners’ reading abilities of learners in early years.