School of Social Sciences (ETDs)
Permanent URI for this communityhttps://hdl.handle.net/10539/37995
Browse
143 results
Search Results
Item An evaluation of genetic editing in terms of its impact on free will, genetic determinism and reason-responsiveness(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Lendrum, Tristan; Leon, Mark; Coates, AshleyGenetic editing has advanced at an ever-increasing speed over the past five decades and has sparked curiosity from all corners of academia. This paper discusses genetic editing in terms of its interaction with philosophical topics relating to the freedom of will. A vast collection of literature has already been published regarding the ethical considerations of genetic editing, however, in this paper I put those concerns to the side and seriously analyse the impact a complete practice of genetic engineering would have on our free will in the context of a moderately reasons responsive framework. Theoretically, the discussion occurs under the theoretical position of compatibilism. The main claim of the argument which develops in this paper is that genetic editing is uniquely positioned to expand our scope of free will in line with a moderately reasons responsive understanding of free will.Item Has the CRRF helped host countries to adequately address the needs of refugees? A case study on Uganda and Kenya(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Tshuma, TruthThe prevalence of war, famine and political instability on the African continent has resulted in large scale migration into neighbouring countries. The long-lasting effects of these conditions have resulted in protracted refugee situations and host countries have reached the stage of being overburdened by hosting refugees. The New York Declaration on Refugees and Migrants (2016) seeks to address this challenge by encouraging host states to integrate refugees into their national development goals through the Comprehensive Refugee Response Framework (CRRF). By so doing, host countries stand to conjointly address the needs of refugees while also addressing the needs of the host community. This is made possible through co-joined efforts of the international community in supporting host countries with funding. Additionally, through this process, the vision of the CRRF is that refugees will eventually become self-reliant through the opportunities provided by the host countries. This paper investigates whether the CRRF has managed to assist host countries to adequately address the needs of refugees. Having used Uganda and Kenya as the main case studies, the results suggest that the CRRF has partially addressed the needs of refugees. The identified shortfall being that there is inadequate funding, as such, the impact of the CRRF is seen only in a select few situations. The main purpose of this study is to encourage policy development. Future research should consider looking into the reasons behind the lack of international commitment. This will be helpful towards finding means to address the root causes for policy developers.Item Rhetoric Versus Reality: Examining South Africa’s Commitment to UNSCR 1820, 1888 and 1889 on Sexual Violence in Armed Conflict(2024) Green, Tshidi Marvina; Small, MichelleThe use of brute force and sexually motivated attacks on civilians has been a feature within armed conflicts for millennia. With the rise and popularity of the Women, Peace and Security Agenda in the early 2000s, greater attention has been demanded to address issues of conflict- related sexual violence. Various robust and groundbreaking resolutions have been adopted and ratified by the UN Security Council to combat the use of rape as a weapon of war. These include but are not limited to UNSCR 1820 (2008), 1888 (2009) and 1889 (2009). Through these resolutions the international community has called for individual nation states to action the mandates outlined within the broader WPS Agenda in relation to conflict-related sexual violence. South Africa, having occupied a leading role in the peace process of various states within the African continent, has been one such nation tasked with fulfilling this mandate through its peace diplomacy and foreign policy. This study examines the degree to which South Africa has adopted and implemented the normative obligations contained within UNSCR 1820 (2008), 1888 (2009), and 1889 (2009), within its peace diplomacy on the African continent. The study employs a case-study analysis of South Africa’s peace deployments in two African states, namely, the DRC and South Sudan. Process-tracing is used to analyse and ascertain the key junctures within its peace diplomacy to determine how the norms underpinning the WPS agenda, in relation to CRSV, have emerged, been adopted, and implemented within South Africa’s peace diplomacy. The study examines these developments through the theoretical framework of norm evolution and norm life cycle theory.Item The gendered barriers women face in politics: The case study of South Africa(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Olivier, Ursulene; De Matos Ala, JacquelineWomen politicians face nefarious and diverse obstacles. Their voices are both needed and lacking in the halls of national decision-making. According to the 2022 Global Gender Gap Report (GGGR) the gap in global female Political Empowerment has consistently remained the largest since the first report was published in 2006. Globally women only have 22% of the Political Empowerment that men have. This research conducts a discourse and content analyses of female political representation in South Africa and whether this translates into better outcomes for gender equality in broader society. It investigates the social constructs of political hegemonic masculinity and political patronage and the role it plays in the political careers of women to reach executive level positions such as becoming a cabinet minister and president. Key findings are gender stereotypes and gender roles found in both social constructs keep women out of political power. Many women politicians also do not champion the gender equality cause in South Africa in support of political hegemonic masculinity and political patronage.Item The State’s Responses to Urban Marginality in Natalspruit(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Gqoboza, Zandile Samantha; Katsaura,ObviousThis research argues that dimensions of ‘urban marginality’ are reflected in South African cities, in informal trading in poor urban peripheries; specifically, in ‘townships’ and ‘informal settlements’. One finds in post-apartheid South Africa, poor urban margins, where individuals are forced to create alternative forms of employment as a means to survive. These alternative forms of employment are part of the waiting experience of the urban poor (Auyero, 2012). The findings of this paper dispute a claim made by Yamada (1996) stating that informal self-employment is by choice and that it is economically sufficient. Contrary to the above claims the research illustrates that this form of employment is forced and is unprofitable and is therefore economically insufficient. This study therefore suggest that the post-apartheid state should formulate policies with the understanding that this sector is forced and is economically insufficient. To illustrate the above, the research focuses on the experiences of informal traders in the trading area of Natalspruit and analyze their relationship with the municipal state in Ekurhuleni.Item Migration, Motherhood and Subjective Wellbeing: Experiences of Transnational Mothers in Johannesburg(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2023-12) Zikhali, Thulisile; Vearey, Jo; Walker, RebeccaThe discussions on feminisation of migration have renewed research interests into the gendered nature of migration experiences. This highlights the implications of cultural norms and values on migrant women. Despite that there is a longstanding history of people migrating to Johannesburg from within the Southern African region, little is written about the experiences of cross border migrant mothers who leave their children behind. This study explores the intersections of migration, motherhood, and subjective wellbeing in Johannesburg inner city, drawing from the experiences of twenty women: originating from Zimbabwe (comprising 15 women), Ghana (consisting of 3 women), and the Democratic Republic of Congo (involving 2 women). Participant observations and semi-structured interviews are methods that were used to collect data in the following three Johannesburg inner city areas: Hillbrow, Berea, and Yeoville. These are migrant-dense urban spaces in Johannesburg. The study used matricentric feminism and constructivism as its philosophical resources. It also utilised concepts of precarity, embodied transnationalism and subjective wellbeing as analytical tools to examine transnational mothers’ experiences. Findings indicate that familial social history and cultural gender norms play a crucial role in shaping perceptions of motherhood and in determining what are seen as “acceptable” ways of mothering. The study also found that there were tensions and contradictions in mothers’ perceptions of motherhood: their convictions on meanings of motherhood and the roles that mothers are expected to play in families were not in alignment with their own contemporary realities. Contrary to studies that have been conducted elsewhere, for example in North America and Europe, this study suggests that transnational mothering strategies in Johannesburg inner city are largely mediated by localised contextual factors such as lack of documentation, unstable jobs, xenophobia and crime. These factors undermine mothering strategies by creating an environment of uncertainty which makes it difficult for mothers to fulfil their mothering obligations, for example, sending remittances on time, maintaining regular cross border communication and regular visits to home. This study contributes to conceptual advancement in transnational motherhood research by bringing the aspect of wellbeing to the fore. It does this by uniquely considering the use of subjective wellbeing in understanding mothers’ experiences and how migration was beneficial to their mothering goals and aspirations. Findings indicate that mothers demonstrated agency in dealing with various challenges. They found migration as emancipatory and they were determined to provide for their children as well as to secure their future.Item Bisexuality in Democratic South Africa: Experiences of Women in Johannesburg(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Khuzwayo, Zuziwe; Roy, SrilaThe field of gender and sexuality studies has been growing in academic institutions since the 1970’s. One of the reasons for its growth is that women across the globe are challenging conservative ideas and norms on how they should engage in romance, sexuality and heteronormativity which has implications for broader society. There has also been an increase in LGBTQI+ rights globally including in parts of the world where historically these identities were viewed as illegal and foreign to the indigenous people. In recent years though, there has also been a growing anti-gender backlash across the globe that has resulted in hard-won legal rights being reversed, or new legislation being imposed that is homophobic and transphobic. When it comes to research on sexuality, studies on bisexuality, however, and specifically research stemming from Global South contexts, is limited. This research contributes to the field of sexuality studies by looking at how bisexual women construct and express their sexuality, looking at multiple factors such as race, class, age and space in the city of Johannesburg. Using qualitative methods of life-history and in-depth interviews conducted during the six years of the PhD, this study shows how each of these factors shapes and influence an individual’s sexuality in a democracy where LGBTQI+ rights exist but are inadequately materialised. Drawing on feminist and queer theory, the study delves into how bisexuality is expressed and performed by women living in Johannesburg, and how challenges in claiming their sexuality exist outside but also within LGBTQI+ spaces. The study shows how queer women continue to carve out public and private spaces for themselves amid high levels of violence against women. Lastly, the research shows the continued regulation of women’s sexuality through heteronormativity in public and private spaces, and what this says about how women living on the African continent claim their sexuality in different waItem Cultural Diplomacy and Soft Power: The Impact of South Korea’s Pop Culture on China and the World(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Jiang, ZhiqiThis research paper, titled "Cultural Diplomacy and Soft Power: The Impact of South Korea’s Pop Culture on China and the World" is submitted by Zhiqi Jiang on August 16, 2024, as a Master’s Research Report in International Relations. It examines the extent to which South Korea’s pop cultural diplomacy has challenged China’s cultural dominance in East Asia and contributed to South Korea’s rise in global soft power since the 1990s. By contrasting the cultural diplomacy strategies of China and South Korea and investigating the achievements of South Korea’s pop cultural diplomacy in economics, international organizations, and foreign policies, the study argues that South Korea’s strategic promotion of its pop culture, including K-pop, K-dramas, and films, has significantly enhanced its soft power. This influence manifests in South Korea’s ability to shape public opinion and influence economic and foreign policies in and with China. Additionally, South Korea has leveraged global economic gains and diplomatic influence through celebrity youth diplomacy to further strengthen its international soft power. The findings highlight the critical role of pop cultural diplomacy in international relations, providing insights for nations seeking to improve their global standing.Item Understanding the requirements and barriers to providing Post-Trial Access (PTA): A review of continued access to effective medicine(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Mthembu, XoliswaClinical trials are essential in establishing the safety and efficacy of investigational products and are a mandatory requirement for the registration of a new medicine. Additionally, clinical studies offer access to new therapies, innovative treatments or more effective treatments which may not be readily accessible to the general population. Clinical trial participants receive investigational medicine during the study conduct phase as a study benefit and as compensation for their voluntary participation. In resource-limited countries, this may be the only option available to access new and effective medicine. Therefore, continued treatment access becomes of greater value. However, providing PTA presents ethical considerations which need to be addressed. The provision of PTA to effective medicine can be viewed as an inducement to join a study and creates inequalities between diseased patients, as it excludes other diseased patients who did not participate in the study or patients who were excluded from participation in the study. However, prior to addressing these controversies, it is necessary to establish first whether clinical trial participants have a moral claim to PTA provision. This report seeks to establish the moral requirement for PTA provision to address the ethical issues around providing continued access to effective medicines outside clinical trial settings. The first two chapters will focus on discussing the evolution of clinical trials, highlighting the ethical issues surrounding continued access to effective investigational products. The principles of bioethics will be discussed in detail in Chapter 2 to draw out the moral claims which mandate the requirement to provide PTA to efficacious medical therapy offered during the study. In Chapter 3, I will argue for the moral requirement for providing PTA using the principles of bioethics as a framework. In Chapter 4, I will discuss the challenges and PTA solutions. In my conclusion, I will reiterate my support for the mandatory requirement and implementation of PTA until the Investigational Product is commercially available and accessible to all trial participants, emphasising the importance of this stance.Item Contesting Heritage: A Political Analysis of Freedom Park and Voortrekker Monument in South Africa(University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2024) Ndlovu, Xolane; Veriava, AhmedThis study critically examines the political and social dimensions of heritage preservation in South Africa, with a specific focus on the contested sites of Freedom Park and Voortrekker Monument. The study is underpinned by a social constructionist framework, which acknowledges the multiplicity of realities and narratives in relation to public memory and heritage politics in South Africa. The research methodology encompasses a qualitative approach, including site visits, archival work, and qualitative content analysis. The theoretical framework draws on Anderson's concept of ‘imagined communities’ to understand the emergence of national identities championed by various political actors in relation to heritage sites. The dissertation explores the role of public monuments in post-apartheid South Africa, the controversies surrounding the Voortrekker Monument, and the creation of counter-structures such as Freedom Park to challenge dominant colonial narratives. It also examines the political symbolism of Freedom Park in nation-building and its influence on visitor perceptions. Ethical considerations were paramount throughout the research process, particularly in conducting site visits and ensuring the integrity and reliability of the data collected. The findings of the study offer recommendations for further exploration of the articulation of heritage sites and the debate by other political actors, such as the Democratic Alliance (DA) and Inkatha Freedom Party (IFP), to potentially illuminate the emergence of an imagined community. Overall, this dissertation provides a comprehensive and nuanced exploration of the political, social, and cultural dimensions of heritage preservation in South Africa, shedding light on the complex interplay of historical narratives, political ideologies, and social values within the country’s heritage landscape.