The protection of personal information act: a critique through the lens of libertarian legal theory
Date
2022-10-31
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg
Abstract
This paper offers a critical analysis of the Protection of Personal Information Act 4 of 2013 (POPIA) and its impact on freedom of trade, occupation and profession (freedom of trade) as found under s 22 of the Bill of Rights in the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, 1996 (the Constitution) from a libertarian legal theory perspective. Owing to a lacuna in South African law, the provisions of POPIA that seem to impede free trade will probably not result in an unconstitutional infringementof the section 22 right.
Those provisions in POPIA that restrict free trade may nevertheless be critiqued from the perspective of libertarian legal theory. More specifically, libertarian legal theory’s rejection of over-regulation. In this research report, the ultimate finding is that the cardinal issue with POPIA is that, paradoxically, and despite POPIA’s proclamation to promote a free-flow of information in balancing such purpose with the Constitutional right to privacy found under s 14 of the Constitution, POPIA serves to limit, over- restrictively, the free flow of information between businesses and business, and businesses and natural persons. The research report conducts a cursory analysis of the right of freedom of trade and investigates certain important provisions of POPIA through a libertarian-legal lens. There are three weaknesses in POPIA that are identified in this research report. Firstly, POPIA has a negative impact on trade because both natural and juristic persons receive data protection in terms of th e Act, whereas in jurisdictions where the GDPR operates, only natural persons receive such protection. It will be shown how this aspect of POPIA is potentially overly onerous on businesses. Secondly, the security requirements under POPIA are not only unreasonably onerous on, and expensive for, companies, to implement, but they are cumbersome, contradictory and vague. It will be shown how this could negatively affect free trade. Thirdly, POPIA’s sections dealing with civil liability are too far- reaching in their consequences of business, while also providing for defences to responsible parties which are prejudicial to data subjects. This amounts to an over- regulation, which is antithetical to libertarian legal theory
Description
Research report submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Laws by Coursework and Research Report at the University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2022
Keywords
UCTD, Personal information Act, POPIA, Protection of Personal Information Act 4
Citation
Meyer, Jonathan Alan. (2022). The protection of personal information act: a critique through the lens of libertarian legal theory [Master’s dissertation, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg]. WireDSpace. https://hdl.handle.net/10539/38617