The management of children with severe acute malnutrition in the North West province of South Africa
Date
2021
Authors
Mambulu-Chikankheni, Faith Nankasa
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Background: Since the 1980s, the World Health Organization (WHO) has been
developing guidelines to prevent and manage Severe Acute Malnutrition (SAM).
However, globally, SAM remains a public health problem partly due to the poor
implementation of WHO guidelines. In 2018, SAM accounted for approximately 17
million incidences of morbidity and was associated with nearly half of the 5.3 million
under-five children deaths globally. In South Africa (SA), although SAM was associated
with 31% of all audited 2016/2017 under-five children deaths, co-morbidities such as
HIV and other infectious diseases contribute to the high prevalence of morbidity and
mortality in children with SAM. Despite South Africa adopting the 2002 hospital level
and 2005 primary healthcare (PHC) WHO guidelines, it still experiences high SAM
related mortality. Studies on the implementation of SAM guidelines report problematic
practices and factors leading to those practices at PHC and hospital levels while
neglecting to focus on the referral and community health care services. This thesis set
out to fill this gap by exploring how the adopted South African SAM guidelines inform
health workers in district health system level to manage severely malnourished
children. Specifically, I focused on SAM diagnosis, stabilisation before and during
referral, inpatient management, and follow-up within a sub-district healthcare referral
system of North West Province in South Africa.
Methods: Guided by a policy analysis triangle framework, a case study design was used
to gain an in-depth understanding of the implementation of SAM guidelines in everyday
contexts by uncovering boundaries between the phenomena (implementation
practices) and its context (underlying factors). Two sub-districts in the North West
Province were selected for this study. The research was carried out at the following
referral levels: sub-district hospitals (n=2), emergency service stations (n=2), PHC
facilities (n=5) and Community Health Workers (CHWs) programmes (n=5). A series of
three studies were conducted to address the objectives of this thesis. In the first study
an appraisal of four SAM guidelines used or adapted to South African referral levels was
conducted. The appraisal was complemented by five key informant interviews, which
were carried out to elicit the comprehensiveness of SAM guidelines in SA. The second
study explored SAM guidelines implementation and related factors within the referral
system using primary data which was collected using in-depth interviews with 39
health workers at various levels of the referral system, a review of 40 patient records,
appraisals of nine facilities using a standardised checklist and 10 practice observations.
The third study focused on the role of CHWs in serving children with SAM using a
review of 20 patient records and 15 in-depth interviews with CHWs and their
supervisors. Thematic content analysis was used to analyse qualitative data from
interviews, observations and appraisals. The quantitative data from patient records
were analysed through aggregation to elicit guidelines administered per under-five
children served at the facility level.
Results: This thesis found that the SAM guidelines used in South Africa had clear
objectives to enhance their implementation adequately and inform PHC and hospital
levels. However, the guidelines to inform processes during SAM referrals were unclear.
The reviewed guidelines documents also lacked additional tools like monitoring/audit
criteria to complement implementation. There were discrepancies in SAM diagnosis,
non-compliance to SAM management guidelines, and varying referral mechanisms
during implementation. Some of the factors that influenced these practices included
inadequate clinical skills among health workers, inconsistent supervision and
monitoring, unavailability of sub-district specific referral policies and tools to support
implementation. Suboptimal national policies to support the availability of therapeutic
food for children with SAM and reliable referral transport also influenced SAM
management practices. Regarding CHWs, they identified and referred SAM cases, but
did not offer curative services of stabilisation before the referral and treatment of mild
cases. Such limitations resulted from restrictive CHW policies, inadequate training, lack
of supportive supervision and essential resources.
Conclusion: My thesis reveals that due to an emphasis on inpatient management over
PHC management and community-based prevention, there was a lack of continuity of
care for children with SAM within the sub-district healthcare referral system. The
absence of referral policies specific to a sub-district and aligned to SAM were underlying
contributors to the dysfunctional state of SAM referral systems. Referral policies should
be revised to address the needs specific to sub-districts. For instance, the scope of
community and PHC levels should aggressively emphasize SAM prevention by
prioritising the treatment of mild cases and provision of continuous care supported by
clear records of care given. The use of a policy analysis triangle framework was
essential in understanding that the SAM guidelines implementation practices were
influenced by the content, which informed the practices, implementers’ attributes and
contextual factors. The need to revise policy limitations on therapeutic food for children
with SAM and curative guidelines of mild cases for CHWs was identified. The two
aspects limited the capacity of lower referral levels to manage mild cases of SAM. The
need for continuous training, provision of job aids and using aids to monitor
implementation practices are recommended as potential solutions to limited health
workers' skills. In addition, creating supportive environments like continuously
financing SAM management activities and auditing referrals systems to ensure ideal
implementation practices could help improve SAM implementation gaps.
Description
A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy