A key that opens every door? rationality under the principle of legality today.
No Thumbnail Available
Date
2019
Authors
Sekhethelo, Maile
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
In recent years the principle of rationality has attracted more judicial attention than any other
principles under the principle of legality. The principle has expanded such that the scope of
what constitutes the principle of rationality and the manner in which the courts apply and
interpret the principle has developed significantly. As it shall become apparent in this paper,
the courts have interpreted the principle of rationality to demand procedural fairness and the
right to be given written reasons. To this end, there is a confusion as to the scope of what
constitutes the principle of rationality. It has also been evident that the courts interpret the
principle to mean whatever the courts want it to mean. It will also become apparent that
rationality may be susceptible to manipulation. It would seem, however, that in most cases the
principle has become a more preferred ground of review than any other principle and thus a
key that opens all doors. The objective of this research report is to explore the principle of
rationality under the principle of legality as developed in the South African courts and
ultimately answers the question of whether the principle has become the key that opens all
doors in cases of alleged abuse of public power. The report finds that rationality is not a key
that opens all doors.
Description
Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of
Master of Laws by coursework and research report
at the University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2019