Triple negative breast cancer in South Africa
Date
2016
Authors
Prodehl, Leanne
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
There were 275 patients with triple negative breast cancer identified out of 1898 patients
(14.4%). The prevalence at Milpark Breast Care Unit was 13.9% and 16.1% at Helen
Joseph Hospital.
135 patients were further analysed. Stage at presentation was IIa and IIb in
approximately half (47.23%) of the patients. Patients presented with large tumours -
57.78% greater than two centimeters, and lymph node positive disease (55.55%). The
majority (72.73%) of patients had high-grade, poorly differentiated tumours. This is
consistent with studies showing that triple negative breast cancers present with more
advanced tumours. There was a non-significant trend for younger patients to present
with more advanced tumours with more aggressive histology.
The triple negative breast cancer is challenging to manage due to its lack of response to
steroid blockade and lack of biological therapy. This was reflected in the number of
patients treated with multimodality therapy. 94.81% of patients had chemotherapy,
59.26% as neoadjuvant and 40.74% as adjuvant treatment. There were 93 (68.89%)
patients treated with radiation therapy.
There was a recurrence in 22.96% of patients, with preponderance to lymph node and
visceral metastases. Recurrences occurred early, the median was 23.1 months and all
had occurred within eight years. Younger patients had more recurrences (32.35%) and
all occurred within six years. Stage at presentation and lymph node involvement were
significantly associated with recurrence.
Complete pathological response to neoadjuvant chemotherapy is associated with
improved outcomes. The recurrence rate was 1.25% if there was a complete
pathological response in both the breast and lymph nodes.
The mortality rate was 19.26% and was greater in younger patients, 23.53% for women
40 years old and younger and 31.82% for women 35 years old and younger. Mortality
was significantly associated with stage at presentation and lack of surgery but not lymph
node positivity.
Conclusion
The prevalence of triple negative breast cancer in two South African breast care units
was similar to some studies but less than studies in West and East Africa. Patients in
these units, similar to other units, presented at a more advanced stage and had poorer
outcomes than luminal breast cancers. Younger patients showed a trend to more
advanced presentation and poorer outcomes than older patients within the triple
negative subtype. This suggests than the outcomes of young patients cannot be
explained by preponderance to aggressive subtypes alone.
Description
MBChB FCS (SA) Cert GIT
Department of Surgery
University of the Witwatersrand