Ubuntu and moral value
Date
2014-02-04
Authors
Van Niekerk, Jason
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
This thesis argues for a perfectionist account of the African communitarian philosophy
ubuntu as the best account of ubuntu qua theory of moral value. Surveying extant work on
ubuntu, it finds that most such work reproduces the ambiguities and difficulties of the
fraught public discourse on ubuntu, or falls to fallacies characteristic of many African
philosophical projects. It argues that the approach which most successfully avoids these
difficulties, thus reflecting the concerns and critical methodologies developed over the
recent history of African philosophy more broadly, is the Analytic approach exemplified by
Thaddeus Metz’ work. Metz makes explicit the constellation of value claims generally
glossed as ubuntu, and proposes an attractive positive account, but does not account for the
aretaic (or virtue-ethical) features integral to and attractive in most accounts of ubuntu.
Seeking an account capable of incorporating the advantages of Metz’ account and these
aretaic features, the thesis proposes two possible bases for such an aretaic account: an
autocentric account, reducing moral value to the agents’ prudential value; and a
perfectionist account, entailing moral normativity from the fullest development of some
essential feature of human nature. The third chapter proposes the best formulation of an
autocentric ubuntu in response to Metz’ objections to such accounts. In light of further
objections, even this proves insufficient to support an intuitively attractive account of
ubuntu. The fourth chapter develops and defends a perfectionist account of ubuntu,
according to Thomas Hurka’s methodology, on which the relevant essential feature of
human nature is our disposition toward relationships of communion with one another. This
feature takes what is relevantly essential to be an emergent property of features already
plausibly essential to human nature – rationality and language-use – and is congruent with
the account of human nature proposed by advocates of ubuntu and African
communitarianism. Since this perfectionist account is coherent and intuitively attractive,
and offers novel, plausible responses to challenges facing aretaic accounts of ubuntu and
ubuntu generally, this dissertation concludes that it is the most attractive account of ubuntu qua theory of moral value.
Description
Thesis (Ph.D.)--University of the Witwatersrand, Faculty of Humanities, Philosophy, 2013