School of Education
Permanent URI for this communityhttps://wiredspace.wits.ac.za/handle/10539/4475
Browse
14 results
Search Results
Item Confronting the ‘pedagogical immunity’ of student teachers.(2009) Rusznyak, L.Student teachers enter teacher education programmes with preconceptions about the nature of teaching that have developed in the course of the years they spent in classrooms as learners. The initial phase of teacher education is a complex process in which many student teachers have to unlearn preconceptions they hold about the nature of teaching that would otherwise constrain their development in learning to teach. This is particularly relevant in the South African context, where the education system has recently undergone radical and multi-faceted transformation. Student teachers do not always get the opportunity to observe supervising teachers modelling conceptually deep, enquiry-based teaching during their Teaching Experience (TE) sessions, so it is sometimes difficult for them to acquire a concept of the type of teaching that university tutors expect. This makes learning to teach particularly complex and challenging. This article reflects on the pedagogical development of a student teacher, Amos, over the four-year period of his Bachelor of Education (B.Ed) degree. It shows how his pedagogical choices were often constrained by the conception he had held that teaching entails ‘providing learners with correct information’. If teacher educators are to enable student teachers to become competent in the practice of organising systematic learning, it is imperative that teacher education programmes explicitly examine, challenge or deepen notions of teaching that student teachers bring with them to their initial teacher education.Item Learning to Explain: How student teachers organize and present content knowledge in lessons they teach.(2011) Rusznyak, L.The ability to organise content knowledge around key concepts is an essential part of what student teachers need to learn in order to teach effectively. This is particularly significant as South Africa's education system emerges from policies which undervalued the role of content knowledge in teaching and teacher education. During sessions of practical teaching, university tutors have opportunities to observe how students understand content knowledge in ways that differ from their university coursework. Students’ understanding of content knowledge manifests in how they select and organise concepts, conduct explanations and respond to learners’ contributions. Lesson observation reports written by university tutors, as they observed student teaching, were scrutinised for comments that prompted student teachers to think about their understanding of content knowledge. A qualitative analysis of these comments shows how opportunities for learning are diminished when student teachers’ grasp of their lesson topic is disjointed, when their understanding of the concepts they teach is merely algorithmic, and when their concept of the ordering principles of the content knowledge is muddled. By considering these aspects of teaching explicitly, university tutors prompt student teachers to consider the epistemological merit of their lessons, thereby contributing to the construction of their pedagogical content knowledge.Item Lesson Planning Guidelines: A scaffold for developing Pedagogical Content Knowledge.(2011) Rusznyak, L.; Walton, E.Lesson planning for student teachers is often regarded in technical terms, merely as the means to ensure effective classroom performance. This approach limits the possibilities that the process of lesson planning offers to the development of professional competence among student teachers. In particular, student teachers need to begin to develop their pedagogical content knowledge (PCK), the capacity to make pedagogical choices that are logically derived from content and contextual knowledge. This article reports on a Lesson Planning Guideline which is used to scaffold the construction of student teachers’ PCK individually by requiring them to consider the constituent parts of PCK individually and in relation to one another during the planning process. This guideline was developed in response to perceived limitations of existing guidelines used in our institution and found in texts for student teachers. Called a “Rationale for lesson design” the Guideline does not attempt to simplify the planning process, but rather enables students systematically to access the complexities inherent in effective lesson preparation. By requiring students to articulate their content knowledge and narrate their pedagogical reasoning in some detail, the Guideline enables students not only to teach with confidence but also to construct PCK.Item Theory for teacher practice: A typology of application tasks in teacher education.(2013) Shalem, Y.; Rusznyak, L.Debates about the relation between educational theory and teaching practice are embodied in assessment tasks that prompt student teachers to relate theoretical concepts and simulated or directly experienced practice-based contexts in relation to one another. To establish clarity on the ways in which theory and practice can be positioned in relation to one another in application tasks, we revisit the debate between Paul Hirst and Wilfred Carr (2005) about the role of theory in and for education. We provide examples of assessment tasks and then present a typology showing how such tasks demarcate conceptual and contextual objects of study in ways that are more or less visible to students. We argue that the more visibly the concepts are demarcated, the greater the possibilities are for student teachers to develop systematized bodies of educational knowledge that are able to provide organizing insights into their developing practice. While we concede that there might be valid pedagogical reasons for doing so, we argue that when conceptual objects are less visible to students, the underlying message that is transmitted to students is that educational theory is not specialized knowledge and is not distinctively different from their common-sense perspectives. This approach is less likely to promote their acquisition of systematized knowledge for and of practice.Item Supporting student teachers through their first attempts at teaching: Possibilities and limitations afforded by school-based and campus based models of support.(2014) Rusznyak, L.; Moosa, M.Student teachers' first attempt at teaching a lesson is a crucial step in their professional development. This paper compares the potential pedagogical learning opportunities and limitations afforded by school-based and campus-based support programmes that are designed to support student teachers in their early attempts at teaching. We use a qualitative analysis of interviews with university lecturers and a quantitative analysis of written feedback provided to student teachers within each of these models. The analysis of our data shows that during the school-based model, students receive retrospective feedback on many diverse issues relating to their lesson, particularly their management of learners. In contrast, the campus-based model offers student teachers an explicit opportunity to work collaboratively on the management of the content knowledge for their first lesson. The campus-based model, despite its numerous limitations, offers possibilities for developing students' understanding of teaching as a complex cognitive practice from their early attempts at teaching.Item Using metaphors to gain insight into South African student teachers’ initial and developing conceptions of ‘Being a teacher’(2014) Rusznyak, L.; Walton, E.Metaphors are a useful way of accessing students' conceptions of teaching and tracking how their conceptions shift over time. This article analyses metaphors for ‘being a teacher’ written by a group of South African student teachers at the beginning and end of their first year of study. The metaphors depict teachers' interactions with learners and reveal how students recognise a specialised knowledge base for teaching and their understanding of learner diversity. One third of students constructed initial metaphors that emphasised teaching as nurturing, an endeavour they associate with particular personality traits but without a specialised knowledge base. We analyse how student teachers' initial and subsequent metaphors reflect significant shifts in their conception of ‘being a teacher’ and we briefly explore how students account for these shifts. Revisiting their initial assumptions about teaching within a programme that offers a coherent conception of teaching enabled student teachers to better understand the goals of initial teacher education.Item Approaches to assessing pre-service teachers’ learning in authentic and rigorous ways: The case of an Inclusive Education module(© UV/UFS, 2016) Walton, E.; Rusznyak, L.Initial teacher education programmes offer inclusive education modules that seek to prepare teachers for teaching diverse learners. While there is growing research on the content and pedagogy of inclusive education modules, relatively less attention has been given to the assessment of these modules. This paper focuses on the challenges of promoting authenticity, academic depth and rigour in inclusive education through assessment tasks. Drawing on Cochran-Smith and Lytle’s (1999) concepts of knowledge for-, in- and of- practice in education, we critically reflect on three approaches used to assess an inclusive education course over a number of years. The first approach required pre-service teachers to articulate their understanding of important concepts associated with inclusive education, the second required them to provide evidence of their ability to use inclusive strategies, while the third approach provided opportunities for them to participate in a research project about inclusionary and exclusionary practices in schools. We find that these approaches represent inclusive education knowledge with different degrees of conceptual integrity and provide opportunities for pre-service teachers to participate in authentic academic and professional practices to different extents. We conclude by suggesting how the assessment of inclusive education can be approached so that neither academic rigour nor authenticity is compromised.Item Why academic depth and rigour in university-based coursework matters for prospective teachers(UV/UFS, 2016) Rusznyak, L.; Balfour, R.; Von Vollenhoven, W.; Sosibo, L.From text: Initial teacher education (ITE) programmes are expected to prepare teachers who have the capacity to develop conceptually strong, responsive and inclusive teaching practices. The extent to which ITE programmes have been successful in this endeavour has been questioned both internationally (e.g. Lancaster & Auhl, 2013) and within the South African context (Council on Higher Education [CHE], 2010). In retrospect, it is not surprising that the review of initial teacher education (ITE) programmes conducted by the CHE between 2005 and 2007 found that the sector was experiencing tension between “the theoretical and conceptual rigour expected of a professional degree and the vocation-specific training of teachers” for classroom readiness (CHE, 2010: 103).Item Making conceptual connections visible to students in professional programmes: The case of initial teacher education(2016) Rusznyak, L.This paper presents a comparative analysis of education courses offered across five South African universities participating in the Initial Teacher Education Research Project. The analysis compares knowledge selected for compulsory education modules that are taken by all student teachers regardless of their subject / phase specializations. All programmes include modules that examine curriculum knowledge, learners, pedagogy and context as objects of study in their own right. However, these objects are studied through different practical and/or theoretical lenses. The extent to which each object is brought into relation with others is also variable and programme design structures suggest that these relationships will be explored in specialization courses. However, it should not be presumed that this will happen without explicit collaboration and coordination. It is recommended that the relations between the elements need explicitly to be designed into the compulsory courses, subject/phase specific pedagogy courses and in the design of the practicum.Item Could practicum placements in contrasting contexts support the preparation of pre-service teachers for an envisaged inclusive education system? A South African study(2017) Rusznyak, L.; Walton, E.In contexts where inclusive education is nascent, teacher educators face the challenge of preparing pre-service teachers for a system that does not yet exist. While this might be possible through universitybased coursework, difficulties arise when so few sites that model inclusive pedagogies are available for practicum placements. This article investigates whether practicum placements in contrasting contexts may prepare pre-service teachers for teaching in an envisaged inclusive education system. We analyse the reflections of South African pre-service teachers who have conducted practicum sessions in two contrasting contexts, neither of which offered ideal models of inclusion. We explore the extent to which moving between contexts enabled pre-service teachers to develop orientations towards teaching and learning that Black-Hawkins and Florian identify as essential for promoting and sustaining inclusive pedagogic practices. With reservations, we conclude that practicum placements over contrasting contexts potentially support the preparation of preservice teachers for inclusive education.