3. Electronic Theses and Dissertations (ETDs) - All submissions
Permanent URI for this communityhttps://wiredspace.wits.ac.za/handle/10539/45
Browse
1 results
Search Results
Item Level of nurses' competence in mechanical ventilation in intensive care units of two tertiary health care institutions in Gauteng(2012) Botha, Margaret LynnStudies generally agree the survival of the mechanically ventilated patient in the ICU is largely reliant upon the competence of the nurse undertaking this highly specialized role (Alphonso,Quinones,Mishra,et al. 2004; Burns 2005) However, an audit undertaken by the Critical Care Society of Southern Africa (2004) revealed that 75 % of nurses working in ICU are inexperienced and do not hold an ICU qualification, and as such are unlikely to have acquired the level of competency required to care for the mechanically ventilated patient (Binnekade 2004). A high index of suspicion exists around the competence levels of nurses‟ currently working in ICU in SA as revealed by local studies (Khoza & Ehlers 1998; Scribante & Bhagwanjee 2003; Moeti, van Niekerk, van Velden, 2004; Morolong & Chabeli 2005; Windsor 2005; Perrie & Schmollgruber 2010). The purpose of the study was to determine and describe the level of competence with regard to mechanical ventilation, of nurses working in ICU, who have varying years of experience and training backgrounds, using study specific designed clinical vignettes, in two tertiary healthcare institutions in Gauteng. A descriptive two phase design was utilized for the study. Phase one comprised the development and validation of three clinical vignettes to determine the level of competence of nurses working in ICU‟s with regard to mechanical ventilation. A modified Delphi technique technique using purposively sampled experts from medical technical and nursing backgrounds was used to validate the three clinical vignettes. Content validity was strengthened by computing CVI of the instrument. In Phase two consecutive sampling was used, and data collection comprised of participants (n=136) completing three validated clinical vignettes in the ICU‟s of two tertiary healthcare institutions in Gauteng. All nurses who participated in the study completed the same three clinical vignettes and demographic data. Nurses‟ perceptions regarding their own level of competence with regard to mechanical ventilation were quantified and compared with actual scores achieved in the clinical vignettes. Descriptive and inferential statistics were used to analyse the data. The level of significance was set at <0,05 and confidence levels at 95%. The competency indicator for the vignettes was set at 75% by the expert group, and nurses‟ level of competence was graded according to vignette score outcomes using a grading scale. Statistical assistance was obtained from a statistician from the Medical Research Council (MRC). Results: Results of the study showed that nurses regardless of training background, age, or experience showed a poor level of knowledge, the average score being 48% for ICU qualified nurses and 31% for non-ICU qualified nurses. There was a small significant difference between ICU qualified and non-ICU qualified nurses‟ competence levels in mechanical ventilation when analysed using a two tailed- t- test (p=0.039). Nurses also experienced a misperception regarding their own competence levels in mechanical ventilation when compared to their actual competence levels as determined by three clinical vignettes.