The subjective meanings attached to Muslim social identity in South Africa.
Date
2010-08-19
Authors
Muthal, Saloshni
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
This study is an exploration into the subjective meanings attached to Muslim social identity
amongst a sample of Muslim South Africans residing in Johannesburg (n = 40). Firstly, this
study aimed to understand how Muslims subjectively represent and understand their
Muslim identity. Secondly, the study aimed to explore the degree to which the negative
perceptions of Islam have shaped Muslim social identities. Thus, Q methodology was used
to research the subjectivity and diversity of meanings attached to Muslim social identity.
Four distinct accounts of Muslim identity emerged in the analysis. The first account (Factor
A) was a dominant identification with one’s Muslim identity that was steeped in Islam. The
second account of Muslim identity (Factor B) was tainted by the negative representations
of Muslims, and as a result of this, was experiencing some tension between the need to
belong to the larger Muslim community with the need to be seen as distinct from other
Muslims. The third account of Muslim identity (Factor C) alluded to differences among
men and women in terms of their interpretation of a woman’s role within Islam, with men
believing that women were given many rights within Islam, whilst women did not feel that
this was so. The final account of Muslim identity (Factor D) brought forth a more
conservative mainstream view of identity that alluded to a struggle to balance the dictates
of one’s religion with that of other identities. The key illumination from this study was that
the Muslim identity was perceived to be under threat from negative representations and this
coloured people’s interpretation of their identities.