Examining constructs of beauty through literature
Date
2009-09-09T10:59:22Z
Authors
Kur, Samantha
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
ABSTRACT
The aim of this research was to explore how literature can be utilised to help
adolescents better understand themselves and the world around them. I focused the
research on the issue of beauty. The research was conducted with a group of three
female Grade 10 learners in a school in a North East suburb of Johannesburg.
The research centred on a study of Toni Morrison’s novel The Bluest Eye and a
workbook created to employ the novel as a catalyst for discussions and activities
around aspects of beauty. This novel was selected because of the presence of the
theme of unattainable beauty. Throughout the research period the learners explored
their own notions of beauty as they read the novel and used the workbook.
The theoretical framework of this research draws on reader response theory as
outlined by Louise Rosenblatt in order to explore how the reading of literature has the
potential to help learners understand the world around them. The research also draws
on the theory of feminist poststructuralism as theorised by Chris Weedon in order to
examine how the learners have come to understand beauty and how they react to the
text. The theory of critical literacy is used to shed light on the possibility of the
learners rejecting any new constructs of beauty. The theoretical framework also
provides a survey of various theories of beauty that illustrate how adolescents are
influenced by a socially constructed Gaze and by the media. The framework also
explores alternatives to the dominant construct of beauty. Lastly, the theoretical
framework discusses how race has influenced constructs of beauty.
The content of the data revealed that the learners were profoundly impacted by peer
gazing. Comments and looks from their peers caused the participants to judge
themselves according to a standard of beauty created by their peers, in turn affecting
the learners’ self esteem. The analysis of the data showed that the media was another
determining factor in the participants’ construct of beauty. The participants, through
a variety of media, absorbed the notion of the ‘beautiful’ female body as the ideal to
which they should aspire. Furthermore the participants expressed a feeling of being
different under the racist Gaze which caused them to question the validity of their
skin colour, their noses and their hair in relation to white normative constructs they
had internalised.
By the end of the research programme the participants seemed unable completely to
move away from the influence of the dominant construct of beauty. They still judged
themselves according to the standards projected by the media and their peers.
However, the analysis of the data also shows how the participants, by the end of the
research, were able to demonstrate some attitudinal change towards their bodies and
to articulate an alternative concept of beauty that included positive personality traits
and objects of non-visual beauty. The participants also exhibited a heightened
awareness of a dominant construct of beauty and actively resisted the dominant
discourse of beauty projected by the media and their peers.
This research proves that the literary experience, as described by Rosenblatt, plays an
important part in the teaching of literature, providing readers with the opportunity to
live through the experiences of the characters in the novel. This research shows that,
to a limited extent, literature can affect the learners’ worldview.