Meaningful form : parallelism and inverse parallelism in Catullus, Tibullus and Horace.
Date
1998
Authors
Van der Riet, Jacobus Werndly
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
All the poems of Catullus and Tibullus and the first three books of Horace's Odes
are investigated tor structures of parallelism and inverse paral.elism (chiasmus) and
thus the extent to which these devices were used is determined. Such structures are
demonstrated for the first time for several poems. Sometimes additions or
modifications are made to the structural analyses of other scholars, and sometimes
their findings are confirmed. The notion that inverse parallelism was seldom used by
Roman authors is dispelled. The freedom with which these devices were used,
resulting in a great variety of deviations from strictly symmetrical structures, is
demonstrated Both common and idiosyncratic features in the use of the devices by
the three authors are shown. Several poems of each author are discussed to illustrate
that the demonstration of a structure of parallelism or inverse parallelism is in itself
an interpretative act, which can at the same time serve as a basis for further
interpretation. In particular it is shown that structures of inverse parallelism often, if
not always, iconically reflect the meaning of the poem (hence the title of the thesis)
This ability o, structures of inverse parallelism to reflect the meaning of the poem
may partly account for the fact that they are used more frequently than are structures
of parallelism. In the poems discussed structures of inverse parallelism iconically
reflect the ideas of reversal, cyclical movement, non-progression/deadlock, balance
and/or contrast and enclosure, as well as combinations of the above, such as a spiral
(both progression and non-progression) or the combination of reversal and nonprogression.
Continuity between the structural methods of Greek and Roman authors
is demonstrated, and a theoretical framework is provided, which answers the
questions how such structures can be determined, and what purposes, both practical
and poetic, they serve. A literary-critical awareness of inverse parallelism in
Antiquity is demonstrated. St. Augustine, especially, has a fairly developed
theoretical fram.. of reference on the subject, in his De Genest ad Littetum
Description
A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Arts, University of the Witwatersrand,
Johannesburg, in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of
Philosophy.
Keywords
Catullus, Gaius Valerius -- Criticism and interpretation., Tibullus, Horace -- Criticism and interpretation., Latin poetry -- History and criticism., Greek poetry -- History and criticism., Parallelism (Linguistics)